Wandering the information superhighway, he came upon the last refuge of civilization, PoFo, the only forum on the internet ...
Der Freiheitsucher wrote:I will not judge any debate with Al-'Alim.
I say that beforehand.
Jina wrote:but I would like to see one poll per each judges so people can vote for their second, third etc. choices.
Der Freiheitsucher wrote:Iff [double F meaning "if and only if"] judging these debates requires NO interaction with Al-'Alim, then I've no problem.
Judges and Scoring
* Judges are awarded their positions by the general membership of PoFo, via a voting process that I set up when it is needed. Occasionally I might be required to step in and judge for a debate or two, or appoint someone on the spot, should we find ourselves suddenly lacking for some reason - but generally speaking, I'm just going to be moderating and administering the debates.
* There are five judges, each with one vote.
* Judges are required (to the best of their ability) to read through the debates, asscess the argument presented therein, and try to objectively decide a winner based upon the merits of the argument as it is presented (regardless of that judge's personal bias on the issue). Judges will not need to intervene in the actual debate while it is progressing, as I am going to be handling all moderation.
* Upon completion of each debate, each judge should write a review of their reaction to the arguments that were presented; outlining why they voted as they did. Besides rendering a verdict on the completed debate and determining a winner, this will also allow all teams to improve their arguments in the future. Again, I will attach these reviews onto the end of each completed debate thread.
* Once elected, judges will continue to judge subsequent debates until they don't want to continue, are unable to continue (say - due to their participation in a debate, or a lack of time), or are removed by me for some other reason. Every so often, I will refresh the entire judge pool with another member's-vote.
Mr Bill wrote:I voted for Boon.
NationaliDemocratiSociali wrote:Why not yourself?
Mr Bill wrote:NationaliDemocratiSociali wrote:Why not yourself?
Kind of self defeating don't you think? I mean, I'm clearly not going to win, and voting for yourself is rather shallow... so instead of egotistically throwing my vote away, I'll place it for someone who I *would* like to see judging.
@FiveofSwords Why will an accountant make a be[…]
What do the tweets say? Read them? They have ex[…]
Dude, YouTube is your source? You are not a serio[…]