Tacit Israeli-Hamas Alliance Against the IS? - Politics Forum.org | PoFo

Wandering the information superhighway, he came upon the last refuge of civilization, PoFo, the only forum on the internet ...

Political issues and parties in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.

Moderator: PoFo Middle-East Mods

Forum rules: No one-line posts please. This is an international political discussion forum moderated in English, so please post in English only. Thank you.
#14574402
Regarding the difficulties of uniting old enemies against the IS, sometime earlier I had likened calling upon Turkey to aid the PYD/PKK to calling upon Israel to aid Hamas.
But according to this AP reporter, for now at least Israel's doing just that.

Israel and Hamas form unspoken alliance against Islamic State group
While Israel and Hamas remain arch-enemies, both have an interest in preserving an uneasy calm that has prevailed since the fighting ended – but the Islamic State group is threatening that.
by Fares Akram
The Associated Press
Published on Sun Jun 21 2015

KHAN YUNIS, PALESTINIAN TERRITORY—Nearly a year after a devastating war, Israel and Gaza’s Hamas rulers appear to have formed an unspoken alliance in a common battle against the shared threat of jihadis aligned with the Islamic State group.

While Israel and Hamas remain arch-enemies, both have an interest in preserving an uneasy calm that has prevailed since the fighting ended in a cease-fire last August — a stalemate that is largely the result of a lack of options on either side.

More than 2,200 Palestinians were killed in last year’s fighting, according to Palestinian officials, and Hamas suffered heavy losses. It is isolated internationally, Gaza’s economy is in tatters and reconstruction efforts have moved slowly. A renewal of hostilities would be devastating for Gaza’s 1.8 million people.

On the Israeli side, 73 people, including 67 soldiers, were killed in last year’s fighting, and the summer-long war disrupted the lives of millions of people as they coped with repeated rocket attacks and air-raid sirens. But Hamas, which seized power in Gaza eight years ago, has survived three wars, and the cost of toppling the group would be extremely high, so Israel appears content to contain Hamas and keep things quiet.

Hamas officials say that efforts are underway, through Qatari mediators, to work out a long-term cease-fire. The deal would call for Israel to ease a stifling blockade on Gaza in exchange for Hamas pledges to disarm, the officials said, speaking on condition of anonymity because they were discussing sensitive negotiations. It is unclear whether any progress has been made in the cease-fire efforts, which include Hamas demands to reopen sea and airports in Gaza. Israeli officials declined comment.

In the short run, the biggest threat to the quiet is a small but growing number of extremists in Gaza inspired by the Islamic State group, who have fired rockets across the heavily guarded frontier in order to undermine Hamas. The militants believe Hamas is soft on Israel and has failed to establish an Islamic state.

That has transformed Israel and Hamas — bitter enemies for nearly three decades — into unspoken allies against a shared threat.

Nowhere is this more evident than in the southern town of Khan Younis, where Hamas militants have been supervising work crews that are opening a road along Gaza’s eastern fence with Israel. The patrols have helped preserve quiet in a volatile area used in the past by rocket-launching squads.

Hamas officials say that maintaining the cease-fire is a national interest. “A young element breaking that understanding is our responsibility and the responsibility of all of us and all the factions to stop him,” said Hamas official Salah Bardawil. “Nobody should break the national understanding in a meaningless way.”

The road work has been taking place as close as 150 metres from the border, an area that Israel in the past has made off-limits. In an unusual scene earlier this month, four Israeli military bulldozers entered a buffer zone to remove brush along the fence. Camouflaged Hamas militants approached the area but did not confront them.

“For sure, there are implicit, indirect understandings by both sides not to attack each other,” said Ibrahim al-Madhoun, a Gaza analyst who is close to Hamas. “The road is a message that there is a flexible political mind in Gaza (Hamas) that can take reasonable steps in the light of any regional or international changes.”

Such a scene would have been unthinkable a year ago, when Israel and Hamas battled for 50 days in their third war since the Islamic militant group — which is sworn to Israel’s destruction — seized power in Gaza in 2007.

Hamas has honoured the cease-fire that ended the war. But a number of small jihadi groups have grown increasingly active in Gaza and appear set on disrupting the calm. They dream of joining Gaza to the IS group’s self-styled caliphate in Syria and Iraq, but because they are too weak to challenge Hamas directly, they have instead sought to undermine it by firing rockets at Israel.

Mkhaimar Abusada, a political science professor at Gaza’s Al-Azhar University, said the rocket fire is aimed at embarrassing Hamas and provoking Israeli military action against the ruling militant group. “Any confrontation will ease the security pressure Hamas put on the Salafists,” he said, referring to ultraconservative Islamic groups.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has said he holds Hamas responsible for all attacks coming out of Gaza and threatened to use Israel’s “full strength” to respond. But so far, Israeli reprisals against the recent rocket fire have been limited to empty training sites, and there have been no casualties on either side.

The Israeli military declined to comment on the matter. But defence officials, speaking on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to speak to the media, said they are aware of Hamas’ efforts to preserve the calm.

In addition to the border patrols, Hamas has arrested dozens of Salafi activists in recent months and set up checkpoints in sensitive areas to look for suspects.

Hamas officials say little about the road patrols. Mahmoud Zahar, a Hamas leader, said the action has helped improve security by preventing Palestinians from infiltrating into Israel and is helping “protect the properties” of people from Israel. He also said the road would help local farmers gain access to lands that could not easily be reached following the war.

Alon Ben-David, the senior military correspondent for Israel’s Channel 10 TV, said Hamas was sending a conciliatory message to Israel.

“What they are broadcasting with those patrols is: ‘We are preventing friction with you (Israel),’” he said. “We are here to prevent fire on Israel.”

But he said the Hamas patrols are also collecting intelligence on Israeli military positions and soldiers. “So this could all in a second turn upside down and become a military offensive manoeuvr. But now their objective is the opposite,” he said.
#14574414
Well he did say "unspoken".
I suppose it may be more of a "non-aggression pact". Both Israel and Hamas for time being won't pick fights with each other and concentrate on fighting IS infiltration.
This seems to be somewhat of a recurring theme over there. A new even more odious fanatical Islamist group rises that antagonizes all pre-existing belligerent parties.
#14580202
I suspect that Israel see's as better the devil you know...shame the US didn't use this approach when dealing with Saddam in Iraq.

ISIS are being viewed and rightly painted as the worst of humanity so it would be a good idea for Israel, Hamas and the PA work together. Would be slightly ironic if a bunch of suicidal Islamic Lunatics bring former enemies closer (they will never been friends, but i am sure all would view not killing each other as a good place to start)

On a wider scale ridding the world of ISIS should be a priority of all nations. They are totally incompatible with any other culture or form of government. The sooner my countries government sees that the better.
#14581669
I don't believe for one moment that Israel would try and do anything that would help acknowledge or legitimise the genuine grievances of the Palestinians. I think it highly unlikely that Israel would consider IS as a bigger threat than the Palestinians, for once, gaining a legitimate and coherent voice against Israeli oppression. Because thats what may happen if Hamas are suddenly painted as the "not so bad guy after all". This may be a case of Israel panicking in the face of a new threat - but I think its only a matter of time before they start to think about how they can cynically use IS - or any other more-extreme-than-Hamas groups - to undermine anyone who presents as a legitimate and believable voice against Israeli oppression.
Russia-Ukraine War 2022

It is sad, the two strongest Slavic nations are k[…]

Rosie Perez said it correctly. If they want to de[…]

Whats "breaking" here ? Russians have s[…]

@Puffer Fish You dig a trench avoiding existin[…]