Pearl Harbor - Politics Forum.org | PoFo

Wandering the information superhighway, he came upon the last refuge of civilization, PoFo, the only forum on the internet ...

The Second World War (1939-1945).
Forum rules: No one line posts please.
By cowofzot
#13426466
& Admiral Kimmel

Kimmel did not merely restate the findings of Morgenstern and Theobald. He presented his readers with a fresh perspective on why the Pacific Fleet came to be based at Pearl Harbor at the insistence of Roosevelt, and how he and General Short had tried, for many months, to remedy the serious short comings of that facility. There were never enough aircraft available to conduct 360-degree searches on a regular basis; the base lacked radar sets and trained personnel, the entrance to the anchorage was so narrow that warships were forced to enter and exit in single file. Kimmel's superiors repeatedly advised him that there was no danger of torpedo attack, because, they were confident, the harbor's waters were too shallow and any airdropped "fish" would simply sink to the bottom (the Japanese solved this problem by affixing special fins to their torpedoes; U.S. Naval Ordnance did not think this was possi ble).

http://www.ihr.org/jhr/v11/v11p431_Lutton.html
User avatar
By Oxymoron
#13426627
1. The Radar was fairly new and its abilities were not yet utilized to the best of its abilities.

2. The failure to have a Base in hawaii would allow the Japanese to dominate the Pacific.
By cowofzot
#13426742
You gotta have a base there no doubt. But Kimmels predecessor was fired for telling Roosevelt the fleet was exposed at Pearl & it should stay in San Diego. Kimmel told him the same thing & was ordered to send it from San Diego to Pearl & shut up, then Rossevelt gave Kimmel the blame after the disaster.

True about radar, British Radar was very unreliable in 1940. Hood didn't get Radar til 1941.


Strangest of all is the Carriers were out to Sea when it happened.

NATO defended Israel against Iranian Attack with 2[…]

- "USA was never a white country!" Th[…]

You're no doubt referring to an earlier version o[…]

Israel-Palestinian War 2023

Conflict is not inevitable when a diaspora returns[…]